Promaster Impulse vs Cityscape: Which Holster Bag?
By B&C Camera | Published: 2026-10-27
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Promaster Impulse Medium Holster Bag and Cityscape 15 Holster Sling Bag to find the right camera bag for your needs.
Quick Answer
Choose the Promaster Impulse Medium Holster Bag for its full rain cover and lower price, or the Cityscape 15 Holster Sling Bag if you prefer a discreet, multi-carry sling design.
Protection and Weather Resistance
The Impulse bag includes a full rain cover for heavy downpours, while the Cityscape relies on its water-resistant fabric without a dedicated cover. If you shoot in unpredictable weather, the Impulse offers an extra layer of security.
Both bags use durable outer fabrics, but the Impulse specifically mentions high-quality SBS zippers for long-term reliability.
Carry Style and Discretion
The Cityscape 15 is a holster sling bag that can be worn multiple ways, making it versatile for travel and street photography. Its design is intentionally understated to avoid drawing attention.
The Impulse is a traditional holster bag—simple, secure, and straightforward. It lacks the sling versatility but is more compact for quick access.
Trade-Offs at a Glance
- Weather Protection: Impulse includes a rain cover; Cityscape relies on water-resistant fabric only. If you shoot in heavy rain, the Impulse is the safer choice.
- Carry Versatility: Cityscape offers multiple wearing styles (sling, shoulder, etc.); Impulse is a fixed holster. For quick changes between carrying positions, choose the Cityscape.
- Price: Impulse is about $23 (catalog price) vs. Cityscape around $38. If budget is tight, the Impulse delivers solid protection for less.
Product Facts
- Promaster Impulse Medium Holster Bag - Grey: The Impulse bag is made of water-resistant fabric and includes a full rain cover for extra protection in heavy downpours. You can confidently shoot in wet conditions without worrying about your gear getting soaked.
Promaster Impulse Medium Holster Bag - Grey - Promaster Cityscape 15 Holster Sling Bag - Charcoal Grey: The Cityscape line is built with lightweight, strong fabrics and an understated look to avoid drawing attention. It blends into urban environments, making it ideal for street photography or travel where discretion matters.
Promaster Cityscape 15 Holster Sling Bag - Charcoal Grey
Which One Fits You?
Best For
- Budget-conscious shooters who want a rain-ready holster bag
- Photographers who need a simple, no-fuss carry for a medium camera setup
Not For
- Those who need a discreet, low-profile bag for street photography (choose Cityscape instead)
- Travelers who want a versatile sling carry option
